Common Thread For IPO's

#1
Dear Alchemist,

Can You Please Start a thread wherein u suggest about which IPO we should go for & keep updating extra ordinary news about them in a single thread.

I wanna say now which IPO we should go for?

We can find this question's Answer anyday, everyday in a single thread.

Waiting for your positive response

Thanks
 
#2
Dear "SARAFSAKET",

This request has already been fulfilled by Alchemist. You can go for latest news of any IPO by clicking on individual thread of that particular IPO link in this forum. No need to merge all that in a single thread, as that will make things complicated. One would be confused whether a particular news is about which concerned IPO. So, according to me, the current set up works best.

Keep it up, AlchemistJi.
 
#3
Dear "SARAFSAKET",

This request has already been fulfilled by Alchemist. You can go for latest news of any IPO by clicking on individual thread of that particular IPO link in this forum. No need to merge all that in a single thread, as that will make things complicated. One would be confused whether a particular news is about which concerned IPO. So, according to me, the current set up works best.

Keep it up, AlchemistJi.
Dear,

Now tell me if u want to find details to invest in IPO. where do you go.

You have to go to every thread .

It is not practical.

that's why i appealed to alchemist.
 
#4
That is the point I want to make. All the details pertaining to a particular IPO is given in the corresponding thread of that IPO.
So, no need to start a single thread. Moreover, if Alchemist or for that matter anyone gives you an investment advice or tells you to invest in a particular IPO and you don't make money in that IPO then you will start blaming that person for your loss. A person can only put facts and figures in front of you and it is only you who has to make final call about any investment. That is what I feel that Alchemist is doing.

Dear AlchemistJi, Please correct me if I am wrong.
 
#5
Threads are practical, Friend.

I agree with gourav. These posts are for discussions only pertaining to respective IPOs. You do need to search For what you want.

Forgive my straight forward words. But forums are for discussion, if you have a particular doubt, post it in a thread or start a new thread if its a new topic, Alchemist or others will definitely answer them.

This is not a Guide to IPO investing like the Google ads claim "Invest in IPO thru Sharekhan" :D, Its just a Rocking Forum!!

:)
 
#6
I agree with gourav. These posts are for discussions only pertaining to respective IPOs. You do need to search For what you want.

Forgive my straight forward words. But forums are for discussion, if you have a particular doubt, post it in a thread or start a new thread if its a new topic, Alchemist or others will definitely answer them.

This is not a Guide to IPO investing like the Google ads claim "Invest in IPO thru Sharekhan" :D, Its just a Rocking Forum!!

:)
Dear Rookie gau,

I respect your thoughts (caused from your posts i discover many things intially), but i want to say only one thing if i respect alchemist's word & thoughts, why cant i know what alchemist is thinking right now.

It is not that i blam him since he is not charging a single penny to us.

You can take a example of edelwiss IPO. I was interested in it & seeing just this thread, suddenly after applying in it i see kolte patil IPO thread and seeing alchemist is saying he is leaving the edelwiss IPO & going for kolte patil. If he can starts his resent views (latest) in a thread then we can know major changes in his move then we can also beniffited.

It is entirly on us what we do or not, but atleast we can know about alchemist latese thinkings on market.

you can change or modify my IDEA but still i wish to see alchemists major theories in a single thread also.

No other can reply in that thread, if anyone have queries regarding any comment of alchemist of that particular thread, he/she can put their query on the related thread.

Dear alchemist, Please comment.

Thanks,

Saket
 
#7
Dear Sarafsaket,

You can find all the posts of a particular member by clicking on their name and clicking on 'find all posts by the user. Or else you can search for all the posts by a particular user in a particular section by going to the search section. I think you really don't know how to surf a forum site. Please go thorugh the FAQ segment. Please don't take my advice otherwise. But, if Alchemist do as per you say, it will be really confusing.

I also request to Alchemist to correct me if I am wrong. Waiting for Comments..........
 
Last edited:
#8
Hi dear,

I also dont feel that all the ipo threads should be in one and only replied by Alchemist. by having it in different threads everyone gets a chance to reply and put his ideas on the company, thus more knowledge adn more analysis. sometimes i fine rookie gou's point intresting. So keep the forum as it is as everyone has some knowledge of stock market and let us share it all. No doubt Alchemist is the biggest GUN in this forum but dont forget smaller one also do fireeeee.:D So take everybody's advise and do what u want.
 
#10
:mad:
seems all r against my thought.

anyway,

Even you can see in all Ipo thread all r asking for next

but still no one is ready to start a thread where alchemist give his latest opinion on Ipo's.

Good Luck Guys.
 
#11
Dear Sarafsaket,

Please don't feel our comments to be against the spirit. You have rose a good point, what we are saying that AlchemistJi is already doing this. I mean what you want Alchemistji to do, he is doing it already. then what the point to start a new thread. this forum is a common platform to share each other views.

Dear Alchemistji, am I correct.

Please comment and correct me if I am wrong.
 
#12
Hi dear,

There is nothing to feel bad. Gouravadv is right ur idea was great but Alchemist is already doing it what u want, why not get some more advice and profit from it. We have given u our point of view, may be we are wrong and u r right, if that is so that maybe Alchemist will provide u what u want. So dont feel bad and :D, u r one of us buddy, take difference in opinion positively.
thx:cool:
 
Last edited:

Alchemist

Administrator
Staff member
#13
Saket,

I do understand your problem.

It is difficult to choose between different IPO's.

=================================================

However, I am not in favor of having a common thread for my IPO views for the following reasons:

- this is forum and meant to be a community. In a community, the views of all members are equally important.

If I has wanted it to be a site for my personal views, I would have made a blog. (In fact I already have a blog, but have stopped using it).

- second, I only want to express my views. I do not want to recommend any stock/IPO to anyone. Different investors/traders have different perspectives.

In IPO's, some look for quick gains, some for safety of capital, some for long term prospects, some for allotment chances...... and some don't look and just jump. :D.

Thus, an investment decision should be made based on the investor's own goals. Giving too much emphasis on views of one or two persons in not a good practice.

- third, a common thread will get very difficult to manage. The problem is that members will ask all sorts of questions and then the whole thread will be a mess. (Even now, each day, I am moving few posts to more suitable threads. This work will only increase as the forum grows.)

To keep IPO-specific questions separate, I need separate threads for all IPO's.

=================================================

I think I will continue with the current format.

Thanks for your suggestions. Hope to get more in the future too. :).
 
Top